Rage Bait Works. Should the Church Do It?

I watched a video this week called “How to rage bait Americans” by a YouTuber named Christophe. He tracks down who’s behind the angriest “news” on Facebook, and it turns out a lot of it is AI-generated and run by people in Sri Lanka, Vietnam, and Cambodia who’ve never set foot in your town. They aren’t trying to change your vote. They’ve just figured out that angry pays and tame doesn’t. The right title triggers an emotional response at a glance, and if you watch the full clip, they get paid.

 
 

I bring this up because I just sat in on a bonus episode of Stronger, the podcast with my pastor, Andy Wood. He and Aaron Graham, who pastors a church two miles from the White House, talked about how Christians should think after the midterms. We titled it “How Should Christians Think After the Midterms?” and the thumbnail says “Do what’s right, not what’s popular.”

 
 

I jokingly texted that we should call it “Blue Wave? Are We Doomed?” It was a joke because there was no way we’d actually use it. Way too rage-baity. We tend to be conservative with our titles and thumbnails, but levelheaded titles lead to low views. That episode is sitting at 2,200 views, which isn’t a great showing for the topic. We may need to take a note from those Sri Lankan engagement farmers.

Would we have gotten more engagement if the title or thumbnail had been one of these?

*These are fake thumbnails I created with Claude

 
Mock rage bait YouTube thumbnail with the words God Is Not a Socialist next to a smiling pastor
 
 
Mock rage bait YouTube thumbnail with the words They Tried to Ban This Verse and a redacted Bible verse stamped Banned
 
 
Mock rage bait YouTube thumbnail with the words D.C. Pastor Warns Christians Are Being Used, with two pastors on red and blue backgrounds
 

I asked Claude to unhinge a bit and do its own engagement farming. These are the results :)

 
 

Should the church leverage ragebait?

More engagement means more views, and more views can mean more impact. Eyeballs can turn into people in seats, and people in seats can turn into disciples. Paul had Timothy circumcised in Acts 16 so they could hear the Gospel, which is a much higher price than a spicy thumbnail. And Jesus was killed because what he said was threatening to the powers of his day.

I do struggle with this strategy. It’s built to grab you while you’re doomscrolling, and sometimes that’s all it is. I tend to land in the middle with how I engage conversations, and starting at the extreme can paint you into a corner. I don’t think the approach is wrong, but a clip can be accurate and still misrepresent the full Gospel. If someone clicks for a fight and finds a pastor asking them to love their neighbor, did I reach them or trick them? How does this impact your reputation in your community over the long term? It’s just 2026 social media street corner sin shaming at times. But street evangelism isn’t all bad. There are ways to do it right and effectively.

So how do you stay competitive on YouTube right now? I don’t think there’s a safe middle, which is a problem for a guy like me. Lean into the controversy, and you’ll get the reach, along with an audience trained to show up for a battle. Stay vanilla, and you keep your voice, but you’d better be at peace with smaller numbers and slower growth.

Pick your road and be ready to ride it, because if you lean into the controversy, it will get rocky. If I’m honest, the next time we title a podcast like this one, it’ll be more aggressive, because we do want to reach more people. But we still won’t use anything too crazy. No Civil War language.

Jay Kranda

Jay Kranda is the Innovative Tech Pastor at Saddleback Church

http://jaykranda.com
Next
Next

God & Glitter